I am so glad to see all the Kosher ones are the ones that smell better!!! Both going in and going out!!

It does come down to personal choice hun. If you can have the HEN program that DD was talking about then I would say the Karicare HA, because allergies can develop over time. If not and if cost is an issue then I would say the Heinz step 2. You can try both and see what she responds best to, but they are all much of a muchness.