We currently don't have recycling at all and usually have a full bin (though that's with a recent move).
Prior we half filled our regular bin (that was a big sulo) and maxxed out the recycling. When we lived in Sydney, what feels like many moons ago, we enquired about getting a small regular bin and the council said fine, but we'll up your rates for your effort!!
I am fairly conscious of packaging and we use cloth nappies as well, so I'm hoping our consumption goes down...would dearly love a worm farm, but DH refuses to have one! He is also another who couldn't care less what goes in what bin, so for him the current situation is great