Darling, I'd wait and see what they come back with, but I personally would probably go with the early evening shift, to stay in the office role. If they're happy to negotiate start and end time, all the better. And you could even ask for four days a week or something, or maybe Sunday to Thursday evenings, rather than Monday to Friday (if you get allowances for the Sunday evenings... might work out to more $$ for you, as well as the Friday and Saturday nights to spend with your DH and family).

Best wishes.