I think I'd go to the school myself and see what I thought of it (particularly the principal and the teachers in general). TBH I have a really hard time evaluating a school on others' impressions (and NAPLAN results, although I would be concerned if there was a particular school in our area which did significantly worse than others, ITMS).
:yeahthat:

I would be going to see both and talking to both principals before even starting to think about making a decision. I would be more inclined to make a decision based on my own child, how the school can cater to them and what I think is best for them rather than Naplan results. Good luck!