i'd visit both & choose the one i felt suited my child/ren better. it doesn't matter how good a school's results seem to be, if it's not the right learning environment for your child, then they won't necessarily do well. i think if it's the right envorinment, then your child will blossom & learn. you could bring up the naplan concerns when you visit the school & see what they have to say?

i don't have a cat, but if i did, i wouldn't eat it
:yeahthat: I think it comes down to how you feel about each school. In my mind, life isn't all about your school results - I'd be less worried about NAPLAN results & more inclined to choose a school that I felt comfortable with in other areas ITMS.