Bake friands and influence people
Paula Goodyer
August 7, 2008
Nix the mix ... homemade is healthier and more satisfying.
Baking cakes and biscuits together is a good first step in teaching children cooking skills but using a packet mix sends the wrong message. You're encouraging cooking but you're also teaching your kids to eat from packets, warns food coach Judy Davie.
Davie is the author of Read The Label, a detailed guide to knowing exactly what's in the food you buy and how to exit the supermarket toting the healthiest choices, from breakfast cereal and yoghurt to olives and curry paste.
There's a good reason why cake mix wouldn't figure on her own shopping list: the main difference between cakes and muffins created from packets and those made from scratch isn't, surprisingly, less time and effort, it's just more additives. Davie's comparison of packet muffins versus muffins from scratch found they took roughly the same time but the packet version had almost twice the sugar and three times the sodium, plus additives including sulphur dioxide, which is considered a trigger for asthma.
It was a similar story with carrot cake. The packet version took the same amount of time as Davie's recipe but while hers had fresh carrots, the packet cake had dried carrot, more sodium, emulsifiers, dairy powder, cheese powder and food colours.
And don't get her started on pancake mixes. Although these mixes are faster - unlike pancake batter made from scratch you don't have to "rest" the batter for an hour before cooking - the trade-off is almost double the kilojoules and sugar.
"With a proper pancake, you have to think ahead to allow for resting time but you're using fresh eggs, milk and some wholemeal flour. With a pancake shake, you're adding water and there's a list of additives.
"Packet mixes don't really save time and there's more sugar. There's also more sodium - perhaps to ensure the cake really rises," Davie says. She puts these mixes in the same category as cook-in sauces - processed foods that give the illusion of cooking from scratch.
Her advice: ditch the mixes and invest in good ingredients for baking your own cakes and muffins - and regain more control over what you eat.
"With the right ingredients you can put a lot of good nutrition into cakes or muffins you bake yourself - though they're no substitute for eating fruit and vegetables, of course. The carrot cake is a good example. It uses monounsaturated fat, fresh eggs, carrot, wholemeal flour and walnuts - there's not a lot wrong with that. And when you're steering your own ship, you can modify the ingredients.
"Reducing the sugar might mean a cake doesn't rise as much but it will still taste good. If you prefer using monounsaturated oil instead of butter, that's fine as long as you're baking a heavier cake, not a Victoria sponge."
Read The Label has good advice on choosing the best baking ingredients. Davie suggests trying spelt flour, which is made from a type of wheat that contains less gluten than modern wheat grains.
"Baked goods made with spelt are denser and tastier, though they might not rise as much," Davie says.
"We've been conditioned by commercial cakes to think cakes must be light and high, but cake textures vary."
Bookmarks