This rule will help the smokers keep smoking, and encourage non-smokers to take it up..
... as if peer presure wasnt already enough, why would the parents of non smoking teens want it done in front of their kids at school all day, by there friends, (who hold all the power!) when it comes to teens?

I have just stopped my DD from having contact with a friend because she is secretly smoking (amoungst other stuff)... if she were allowed to do it at school, how many of her friends are going to try it, and then get hooked??

Thats NOT why I send my kids to school, to learn how to smoke!!