We had a wishing well for our wedding.

I think they are fine however I don't know that I like the idea of a wishing well for all occasions. I have seen them done for the engagment party then the wedding also, I seem to think that is a little bit rude.

I love buying a present however sometimes a wishing well is so much better esp. if the money is to go towards whitegoods or a holiday, rather than a heap of little appliances that clog the cupboard.