My girls normally get the 'wow, they are different names' response.

But your story reminded me of some close friends of the family. When these friends announced they were expecting their third bub no one could have ever picked what they would call their little boy... They named hiim Gordon! When his birth was announced family and friends went into shock with the name, and not a single person liked it (well besides the mum and dad of course!). But now (20yrs on) everyone will say how they didnt like it at first but the name totally suits him and has since the day he was born!!