I go ditto to 'Michelle's' post... I have both the ERGO and Peanut Shell and love them both.

I call teh ERGO 'the boot' and the Peanut Shell 'the thong'! The 'boot' takes a couple more moments to put on but you can walk longer distances and still be comfy, while you just stroll to the round-the-corner-shop in your 'thong'!!

Both slings are great but do different things at different times....

I have just been 'web surfing' and noticed that the Babes in Arms website has both carriers on special at the moment! 20% OFF Indigo ERGOs and Microfleece Peanut Shells!! Good luck!