My DS's comfort thing is his doona. Even though he has a pillow and you lay him down on it, he will move up the other end of the cot and snuggle with his doona. On hot nights where i have taken the doona out of his cot to give him more space, leaving him with a sheet, he cries and wails until i put it back in.. crazy child!

When i was little i had a teddy called "teddy". We went up to brisbane (drove) and on the way back when we reached about Coffs Harbour i realised i didnt have Teddy. My wonderful parents turned around and drove back to Brisbane to get him. The things parents do hey.

Only thing i can suggest is take your DD shopping and let her pick out a new toy?
If not, i hope you can find another one.