Interesting conversation girls! Well i'd have to agree with Nic based on my own personal experience and feelings towards my c/s. I would be extremely disappointed if i discovered that a VBAC was Non-negotiable in my next preg!!!!!!!! Perhaps it does have to do with the incision but i'm sure this woman would like an explanation...it is her body afterall! If it's not a big issue then ok - but if she did desire the opportunity to try a VBAC she should get a 2nd opinion.

Helen - best wishes for the 17th...will be thinking of u
Linda - yeah my scar definately gets itchy at times. If i'm wearing a belt i just pretend to be adjusting it - lol.