thread: we disagree

Hybrid View

Previous Post Previous Post   Next Post Next Post
  1. #1
    Registered User

    Jul 2009
    Orange, 2800
    202

    I haven't been in this position, but I've heard alot of good reviews about the Penn & Teller Bullsh*t episode on circumcision ..

    Also, Maybe get him to watch a video of the actual procedure? Theres plenty on youtube.

    I have the same stance as mummydreamer ..

    Good luck x

  2. #2
    Registered User

    Oct 2006
    Sydney NSW
    4,837

    Deleted this post as I got a bit fired up and i think it was just overtiredness which will help no-one!!!

  3. #3

    Feb 2008
    With my awesome cherubs
    2,975

    I have listened to his point of view its something we have discusses since having our first child together (3 years of point vs point) Im not saying our son wont be circumsised, he will be IF he chooses to be, i think its like ear peircing I wont do my girls ears until they tell me they want it done. How do i know as a newborn my son wants this done? I just think as a human being they have the right to choose there aare actually a lot of men out there who hate the fact it was done to them i dont want my son (if i have one or 2!) to feel that way iykwim

  4. #4
    Registered User

    Jul 2009
    1,973

    Peaceful parenting on FB has lots of great info/links stories on it

  5. #5
    Registered User

    Feb 2009
    Brisbane
    1,070

    I was lucky that DH is uncircumcised and never wanted our boys to be, so there was no argument.

    Maybe the 2 of you could both agree to put your opinions aside and research together on both sides of the debate. You might find that once your DH sees how it is done and why so few boys are done now, he will agree with you.
    It might also be worth pointing out that while he is OK with being circumcised, not everyone is. I know my father resents his parents for having removed a perfectly healthy part of his body without his permission. On one of the Jon Saffran shows he was talking to Jewish men who wanted their foreskins back and were going through a tortuous process to stretch what remained after circumcision out to create a new foreskin. Surely if some men feel strongly enough to do that then the decision should be left till later when the owner of the penis can decide for himself?

  6. #6
    Registered User

    Feb 2009
    Brisbane
    1,070

    Whoops, MrsS, you just posted most of what I said while I was writing.