12

thread: How effective was Weight Watchers?

  1. #1
    Registered User

    Aug 2006
    On the other side of this screen!!!
    11,129

    How effective was Weight Watchers?

    Hi all,

    Since we've moved I'm thinking of starting up on Weight Watchers instead of finding a new dietician (for weight loss purposes). Just wondering what your experiences with WW were like.

    Was it useful? Did you lose much weight? Did you keep it off? Were the meetings helpful? What did it do for your motivation levels over a longer period of time. Any other comments (or warnings hehe)?

  2. #2
    queenbee Guest

    Weight Watchers is fantastic. I am on it. I have been on it for many years on and off but recently joined online. I think they have a special going at the moment if you join online. I can eat WHATEVER I want within reason. There are no restrictions. I have lost 4kgs in 4 weeks and have 7kgs to go!

    I like online because I just set up my laptop on the table each day and record what I eat as I go. I don't find it time consuming at all. I can save up points every day to use on something special at the end of the week.

    It is excellent and not a diet, it is virtually healthy eating. I find that because it is not a diet, it is a complete lifestyle change, it is not like I have food delivered and then when I have lost the weight, I don't know what to make for myself and quite easily would no doubt put it back on. It may work for some but definately not for me, I like to cook my own foods and know that everything I eat is healthy.

    Good luck, if you need any help, PM me, I love WW!!!

  3. #3
    Registered User

    Aug 2006
    On the other side of this screen!!!
    11,129

    So what do you actually "get" as an online member?

    The website isn't really too clear on what you're paying for, kwim? As far as I can tell it costs more to go to meetings, but if you choose that model you also get all the info online as well? Is that right?

  4. #4
    queenbee Guest

    yes you have support online, it is excellent, you have a points tracker, weight tracker etc. they have forums also where you can talk to other people. they have a load of recipes. it is definately more expensive to go to meetings however in saying that, some people need that motivation to weigh in every week at a meeting place and have support face to face. i have been to meetings years ago and i must say, they are excellent. but online suits me better as i have a little one and very motivated this time to do it myself.

  5. #5
    Registered User
    Follow Pandora On Twitter

    Jan 2005
    cowtown
    8,276

    I did it for 2-3 months until I found out I was pg with this bub and found it really good.
    I did the unlimited membership which I think is around $50 a month, includes all online access and unlimited meetings - I find I do a lot better if I go to meetings than just online.
    I will be joining back up once I have my 6 week check after bub is born as they have a b/f points plan that I can do, and Im hoping to convince DH to join up as well.

  6. #6
    Registered User

    Aug 2006
    On the other side of this screen!!!
    11,129

    QB - thanks very much, you're very helpful!

    Just another Q - did you lose weight every time you were active in the program? Was it just as good every time?

    ETA - Rayray, did you go to weekly meetings? What was the best thing about them?

  7. #7
    queenbee Guest

    Marydean, I always lost weight on the program, it is excellent.

    I joined end of December for $89.95 for 3 months! They had a special going save $24.95 (one month's worth) - hopefully they still have the special going!

    Good luck and any questions, feel free to ask

  8. #8
    Registered User
    Follow Pandora On Twitter

    Jan 2005
    cowtown
    8,276

    yep I went to weekly meetings. For me its more about having to face up to the scales every week (and knowing they are calibrated and not wrong like ours). A lot can depend on the leader - we went through 2 and the second one was a lot better than the first one, first would just read from paper through the outline, the second one was a lot more personal and interested. Its good to see people in the same position as you who are all going through the same thing.

  9. #9
    Registered User

    Aug 2006
    On the other side of this screen!!!
    11,129

    Rayray, that's the same reason I want to go to meetings! Having a person to face when you step on the scales means you can't really make any excuses LOL.

    I must admit, I've been a bit anti-WW all these years after a colleague was doing it at work. She would eat these tiiiiiiny quantities of food, it just didn't seem normal. Who eats only half the tub of yoghurt or half an egg, for crying out loud?! Plus she didn't actually need to lose any weight at all in the first instance, to look at her. Since then, I've been eating some of the WW brand food to keep my gallstones under control, most of it is actually quite good and substantially lower in fat than comparable brands, kwim? Made me think twice about the whole WW experience.

  10. #10
    Registered User

    Dec 2007
    Adelaide, SA
    896

    Hi i have just joined, i joined and am doing unlimited so i can go to as many meetings as i like in a week and i also have etools which is the online stuff ( communitites, recipes,trackers etc)
    I have done weight watchers before and lost 30kgs , hmm then i feel into bad habits, just as i got back into shape i fell pregnant so here i am again. I am doing the breastfeeding program so slow and steady is the aim that way im hoping to avoid upsetting my milk.

  11. #11
    Registered User

    Aug 2006
    On the other side of this screen!!!
    11,129

    Can you set your own pace for weight loss? Ie if you only wanted to lose 1 kg a month would that be ok or do they try to get you losing more than that?

    Tan was it harder losing weight - I see in your ticker you have insulin resistance iss-ewes?

  12. #12
    Registered User

    Dec 2007
    Adelaide, SA
    896

    Hi Marydean.
    Yes you set your own pace , there is no set amount that you have to loose, you do it your way. i am setting myself 500grams a week. sometimes i will loose more and sometimes it may be less but it doesnt matter either way.
    Losing weight is hard work for me no matter what i do. I figure that i better do it now as i know it will only get harder for me as i get older.
    I dont want to get diabetes and i am in the high ratio of getting it, i have family history, PCOS and i am insulin resistant and overweight. So i am doing it
    to avoid this.

  13. #13
    Registered User
    Add krysalyss on Facebook

    Feb 2007
    on the move.....
    2,745

    I have been to WW a couple of time and my mum has been numerous times. It may work for some people but not for me because it is unsustainable for me. I am having more success now by myself just increasing my exercise and cutting out some of my really bad habits but not going too far with cutting back food. I think it is easy to lose weight quickly for the first month and then to put it back on because the food is cut down so much so quickly. If I did it again I would give myself more points then they give with a view to possibly to cutting down later when my body has adjusted.
    Hope I have given a slightly different viewpoint.
    Last edited by krysalyss; February 2nd, 2009 at 11:12 AM. : meant 'unsustainable' not 'sustainable' whoops

  14. #14
    Administrator
    Add Rouge on Facebook

    Jun 2003
    Ubiquity
    9,922

    It was great whilst I was on it, but my body would store as soon as I stopped, and both times I did it I gained more weight afterwards and not from doing anything badly. I know now its not right for my body as I have metabolic issues but I do know it works for some people. I think the most important thing is not every diet works for everyone, and if it works for you great, if it doesn't try something else

  15. #15
    Registered User

    Aug 2006
    On the other side of this screen!!!
    11,129

    Thanks Krysalyss, what you're saying is they just didn't allow enough food! That's something I learnt from the dietician, you can't just say x calories = a weight loss. Other factors such as activity, height, starting weight - all mean that you may need to eat more than someone else attempting to lose weight. At the end of the day, it's got to be able to fit in with the rest of your lifestyle or it's not worth it.

  16. #16
    Registered User

    Jul 2008
    Melbourne
    3,244

    i've done the online version twice - once with success and once without!

    the first time i lost a bit of weight and was going well but then i moved back to australia from the uk & at that time they didn't have the online version here (i don't think).

    last year i decided to give it another go because i knew i'd done alright the time before. unfortunately this time it just didn't work for me. maybe it would have been better if i'd gone to meetings - i know of a few people that have had success this way.

    as you say, it needs to fit with your lifestyle & be something that works for you. while boundaries are sometimes a good thing, as soon as i feel like i'm being restricted, i want to rebel i'm better setting myself targets - i.e. to eat x amount of protein, x amount of fibre etc because that motivates me & i end up eating more healthy food by default!

  17. #17
    Registered User

    Apr 2008
    Adelaide
    1,741

    Hi mary dean ww worked for me I was overweight as a teenager and joined ww and got down to a healthy weight and maintained that for 5 years until I fell pregnant with dd1. I then rejoined ww online after I couldnt lose the baby weight on my own, it worked for me again but then I fell pregnant with dd2 and have once again joined ww to lose the baby weight. I am breastfeeding and find I am not hungry on the plan and have lost 3.5kg in a month (they reccomend around 500g a week loss if you are bf to maintain supply)

    I find I didnt put weight on once I stopped tracking my points (similar to calorie counting) if I just tried to eat healthy and doing ww helps you get into good habits. Like queen bee with little ones I find online useful because all the food info is at your fingertips and you don't have to worry about finding babysitters to go to meetings but each to their own

    wether you join ww or not good luck with your weight loss

  18. #18

    Oct 2008
    2,880

    I lost 15kg on weight watchers in 14 weeks. I found it really helpful in losing weight.

    As a way of life though, i don't follow it any more. I find that calorie king is much better and means that I eat healthier. Counting points for me became tedious and annoying and not something I think can be done for life.

    Healthy diet and exercise works every time!

    Good luck!

12