I think it's a legitimate option that is abused.

In 99% of cases its simple, energy inout far out weighs energy output. And there seems to be an increase in people having the surgery thinking it's the easy way out.

I actually know a number of people who have had lap banding, most have put 60-80% of the weight they lost back on 5+ years later.

A lot of people defend the surgery saying people see nutritionist and what not throughout but most people over eat for a reason and if that reason isn't identified and dealt with no surgery or diet will work.

I also don't see a need to have to "cure" over weight people, not everyone wants to fit into the xyz mould and are quite happy the way they are. Skinny people are also a drain on the health system.

I don't think tying a band around your gut to make it half its size or stapling your stomach in two should be taken so lightly as it is now. Its major surgery. My mum still 10 years later has problems with her band and vomiting because food gets stuck, this is going to have major health implications as she gets older.

I hope we can one day move away from having to "cure the fatties" and just except people will always come in different shapes and sizes.