I'm not sure about the papasan swing, but I recently bought a bright starts one that was on special at target.

With DD we had a baby love high chair that was a swing too. It was on loan, so we don't have it this time. It also wasn't suitable for little bubs as it was too upright.

I found it great for "witching hour" Often DD would be tired and grouchy, but it was too close to bedtime for a sleep. She would happily have a short nap while swinging without it throwing out her normal sleep times.