DSD Potentially Moving Out To Friend's And Friend's Parents House - Could This Work?

[fionas]

You might not like my response but I think another women shouldn't be made responsible for your daughter. I'm sure she won't want to police her all the time and will eventually cause problems. It sounds like you could use some help. Maybe go see someone about her behaviour without her if she won't come with. In a few years time when she is all grown up and past this stage, the thing she will remember the most is when she was really in need of guidance and support, her parents threw her away for the other children. That's what I would think. I hope you can come to a solution which sits well for all of you. Having teenagers can be the most difficult thing you do in your life. I had a difficult few years when I was a teenager but my parents never let me leave and I thank them for that. They were always there for me no matter what I got up to and I eventually grew out of it and now have a wonderful relationship with my mother. I understand she is your step daughter so you might not have that connection with her and you will definately have it with your kids.

We HAVE been to a counsellor who says there are a few options. Have her living with us with MUTUALLY AGREED boundaries. We've done this. We sit down and work out what's reasonable with her. She agrees to the boundary, then breaks it days later. Option 2 is that she lives with us with no boundaries. That's not going to work either because she simply doesn't want to come to Woodend, boundaries or not. Third option is that we throw her out. Not prepared to do that. Fourth option is that she lives somewhere we know she's safe. That's what we're considering. We are NOT forcing the friend's mother to have her - she is weighing it up herself. They get along.

[PumpkinZulu]

I agree with what you're doing hun, I think it's your last option right now. LOved your post about how you can't revolve the family around her, and that if there weren't a billion other things going on right now you would be more capable to deal with her

I reckon as long as there are set rules at this woman's house (which you said you will be making) and your DD's mate's mum knows what she's in for, and I agree with others, she pays her own way (because it's the real world) then it could be just what everyone needs.

[LimeSlice]

So what you are saying is that she isn't a big enough priority for you to give her that attention she so clearly and desperately needs.
Not sure I would be thrilled if you offloaded her onto me, so not sure what you think this other woman is going to do to raise her when she has absolutely no connection to her or obligation to do so.
Why is she getting a choice to move to Woodend? She is a child. The family is moving to Woodend, she is either in the family or she gets on a plane and goes back to her mother - why are there any other options? I just don't get it.

I was her and I guarantee you, being allowed to move out of home when I was 16 was the WORST thing that happened in my life, and both my parents regretted it. You, and more importantly your husband, have a responsibility to this girl, please don't handball the problem to someone else because it is all just a bit too hard. Been there and it doesn't always work - and cerrtainly isn't fair on the other family.

[fionas]

Right now Limeslice, no she's not our absolute top priority. I'm disabled and I'm pregnant and I don't want to lose this baby. Go figure.

We can't force her to come to Woodend. What are we meant to do - tie her to a chair? Because that is what it would take.

And FWIW - SHE wants to move to her mate's house and the mate's mum wants to have her.

DP moved out of home at 17, I moved out of home at 18. And we supported ourselves.

[Mum2Romone]

QUOTE : Right now Limeslice, no she's not our absolute top priority. I'm disabled and I'm pregnant and I don't want to lose this baby. Go figure.

wow this is such a horrible thing to say , maybe if she were your daughter, you'd have time for her. ????

my brother thought he was old enough to move out and moved in with someone who led him down the wrong path, If you and your husband arent there to guide her , do you expect this other parent to take over?

I feel for Fiona as my mum too had many sleepless nights worrying about what to do about my brother. Her solution was to let him go So she didnt have to deal with it. 9 months later Hes into all sorts of crap and has had 3 car accidents driving around with the morons he lives with. Once they are gone, thats it, They wont magically see the light and be good and come home. You are letting her out in a world that its obvious she isnt prepared for yet !!!! and hanging up your step parent gloves , from where in sitting..... You will only have many more sleepless nights worrying about her once shes gone !!!!!!

[Winter]

wow this is such a horrible thing to say , maybe if she were your daughter, you'd have time for her. ????

Umm, any chance you'd like to come back in with your Belly Belly hat on and start again? There are ways of saying things...looking forward to Take 2.

[fionas]

Hooley Dooley mum2romone you clearly have never read any of my numerous threads about my stepdaughter or my current health.

Lulu yes the very same hairdressing friend who is actually lovely but now can't buy more supplies for her little business because stepdaughter owes her so much and she was silly enough to trust her. We're having her over tomorrow to try and sort something out.

[Lulu]

Fi, as I speak - the daughter I locked out of my house for 2 weeks as a consequence of her crap behaviour - is at her Yr12 formal, in a stunning dress she paid for herself, in a limo and with her hair done (paid for lol) and on her way to studying medicine at Uni.

SDD will survive - however she does. When she leaves she will start writing her own book. It will be hers, with all her choices laid down in back and white. She knows she has a warm home to return to if she leaves and things go bad, and she will be able to make the choice for herself. She has options, many kids don't.

[anney]

Fiona,
My sister is just coming out the other side of a similar situation to yours. One of her DDs at 15 was not wanting to go to school, going out and not coming home and had a bad relationship with her father and didn't want to live with the rules at home. She ended up "unofficially" living with the family of her best friend. of course my sister was worried the whole time but my sister and the single dad that my niece was living with had a good relationship and would talk about what was going on all the time. I think you probably have to think about whether the parenting style of the people she will be living with is OK with you. As you need to feel comfortable with that.
While I agree with LS,that she is still a child, you are correct - you can't make her do anything she does not want to do. Some kids just go through this bad stage and you just have to hope they get through it without anything really bad happening. My niece is now back living at home and is turning 18 next month is everything has worked out relatively well. (except that she did not go back to school and has not really worked or got an education ). I am not sure about the board issue. I guess if you give the parent what you would be paying for DSD anyway then that would be fair but I think DSD does need to take some responsibility for money.

[Bumperstump Cummerbund]

So what you are saying is that she isn't a big enough priority for you to give her that attention she so clearly and desperately needs.
Not sure I would be thrilled if you offloaded her onto me, so not sure what you think this other woman is going to do to raise her when she has absolutely no connection to her or obligation to do so.
Why is she getting a choice to move to Woodend? She is a child. The family is moving to Woodend, she is either in the family or she gets on a plane and goes back to her mother - why are there any other options? I just don't get it.

I was her and I guarantee you, being allowed to move out of home when I was 16 was the WORST thing that happened in my life, and both my parents regretted it. You, and more importantly your husband, have a responsibility to this girl, please don't handball the problem to someone else because it is all just a bit too hard. Been there and it doesn't always work - and cerrtainly isn't fair on the other family.

Wow, harsh much? I think its fairly obvious how much Fiona's tried to put into this situation, and I think it also shows just how much she DOES care by the fact that she is even trying to find an acceptable compromise, rather than just dragging the girl along. My sister was also her, and is now 23 and married with 2 kids - and still tells Mum she should've just let her move out when she wanted to. And then there's my youngest sister, who constantly reminds Mum that she never got any attention because it all went on the 23 y/o. Damned if you do, damned if you don't! But I really don't think its constructive to tell Fiona she's handballing the problem when she's clearly NOT.

Of course, all my humble opinion, and all said with lurve

[meow]

She may be totally different in a new environment and settle down for a bit at her friend's place. I think it's worth a shot. We had a family friend stay with us for 6 months to finish year 10 when her family moved away. She didn't have the troubles your daughter is having but just to let you know that these things do happen and it doesn't mean you are abandoning your daughter.

Perhaps let her know it's a temporary thing as you want her to move with you but you understand her desire to finish out her schooling at her current school. If things don't pan out in the short term, or by the end of the year then she can move with you and finish year 12 at Woodend. By which time your second baby will have arrived so you will be able to move again, she will have had a break and perhaps things will be smoother. The change of school could also be a benefit to her to break her current patterns.

[LionsandBears]

From what I've read of your previous threads, I think she's driven you to breaking point. And I don't think she's your top prioity at all - your family is and she's made it clear she doesn't want to be part of it. If she wants to go, let her go.

I disagree with paying her board AT ALL. She has a home. If she doesn't like it, then she can act like an adult and pay her own way. If she comes to an agreement with her friend's mum, then that's up to her. This may sounds cynical, but if you go 70/30 with her, then expect that your 30% will be paid, the 70% won't and then you'll be pressured to pay the rest. Of course it's good you're involved in discussing things with her friend's mum, but DO NOT agree to comitting money to anything. She's shown she'll abuse the situation if allowed to. She can get a job if she wants to be independent.

It almost seems predictable that she'll soon wear out her welcome at the new place and have to find something else. On the other hand, maybe seeing how other people live will teach her some respect. Either way, it probably best for the rest of you if she's not around anymore. From that I mean, you can regroup, live without the stress and hopefully develop a better relationship.

Personally, I think you've been bending over backwards for her and it's enough.

[fionas]

I hear what you're saying tashybabe - there's a glimmer of hope in the fact that I think she's starting to 'get' it. She's attended all classes at school for the last three weeks and all her exams this week despite the fact that she's been staying at a friend's place. So that's good. However, I'm not sure she's doing it because she values her education now or because she knows she won't have a leg to stand on with us or her friend's mum if she keeps banging on about how she doesn't want to go to Woodend because she wants to carry on at her current school. Hard to say you don't want to move schools if you get all Fs and have 39 absences in a few months (which was the situation a month ago).

Anyhow, on the board, I think this might be fair all round. I will look at what the guidelines are in terms of how many hours per week VCE students are advised to work. I think it's about 15. Then I'll find out what Maccas pays per hour. That will give me a figure that she can reasonably be expected to earn if she keeps up her VCE studies and then we'll figure out what proportion of that she should spend on board, what she gets to keep and whether there's any shortfall between what she can earn and what the mum wants in board. That way, she has a vested interest in not only getting but also keeping a weekend job AND not staying out so late that she can't work the next day.

We'll also make it a condition that she has to continue VCE.

Still not sure on the house rules - will wait to see what the friend's mum has to say about that.

[Lulu]

With her behaviour I wouldn't be encouraging her to live anywhere else. It sounds like she's screaming for attention and wants a parent

So what you are saying is that she isn't a big enough priority for you to give her that attention she so clearly and desperately needs.
Not sure I would be thrilled if you offloaded her onto me, so not sure what you think this other woman is going to do to raise her when she has absolutely no connection to her or obligation to do so.
Why is she getting a choice to move to Woodend? She is a child. The family is moving to Woodend, she is either in the family or she gets on a plane and goes back to her mother - why are there any other options? I just don't get it.

I was her and I guarantee you, being allowed to move out of home when I was 16 was the WORST thing that happened in my life, and both my parents regretted it. You, and more importantly your husband, have a responsibility to this girl, please don't handball the problem to someone else because it is all just a bit too hard. Been there and it doesn't always work - and cerrtainly isn't fair on the other family.

What horrible responses, the pair of you should be ashamed of yourselves. I'm certainly glad I took my own story into the Private Support Group rather than risk this sort of response from people who clearly have no idea of the situation, or have bothered to check out the (many) previous posts to get an idea OR even trying to word your posts a little less harshly.

FWIW -MY situation with my daughter was tearing me and my family apart, I am aware of how hard Fi has worked to try and come to a happy outcome in her situation and FYI, we are not the only members of Belly Belly struggling (shedding tears and not sleeping) searching for help, seeking answers from others and at a total loss. Be careful how you post.

So go on girls, check out my threads, I've come out of the Private Areas and updated my story so you are welcome to come sling some arrows down there instead - I've come out the other side with a happy ending (after NOT allowing my child to treat others like dirt, and learning consequences), but I probably I won't be as graceful as Fi.

[LimeSlice]

I beg your pardon Lu, but I was under the impression the OP asked "what do you think?", not "make me feel good about the decision I have clearly already made but only answer if you agree with me".

I do not believe in this case (IE - has NOTHING whatsoever to do with you or your situation, as that is not what I was asked about, nor do I know much of, whereas I have read I think nearly ALL of Fionas previous posts about DSD and the situation) that letting her run away is an appropriate solution for ANYONE involved, least of all DSD herself.
Nor do I believe it should come down to anyone else to parent this child when clearly her father has ASKED for this responsibility and allowed her to come over from the States. All parties were aware of her behaviour and problems before she arrived, and from what I can gather, these were a very huge part of the reason she was brought to live with her father and Fiona in the first place. This is not a new evolvement, it is the standard.
If Fionas and her husband are in a situation now that means her behaviour has made their family unliveable, then I simply asked why they were bowing to this little twerps wishes and allowing her to get what she wants - which is to move out and not be beholden to any parents or rules (clearly think we have all stated this is the case) - and why she is not simply put back on the plane to go and live with her mother - the other PARENT.
For me personally, if this was me in the position of this other friends mother, I would feel obligated to take this girl in, given Fionas health and situation, and knowing there really wasn't any other option for DSD and the family. And I do not believe it should be any one else responsibility to deal with DSD's behaviour.
For example, what if something should happen to her whilst in the care of this woman (and she is still only 17)? What is she gets pregnant? Gets involved with drugs? Goes missing? Gets raped? Whose responsibility is that? Who is going to be worst off then? No doubt everyone will feel bad, but is this other mother going to wear the burden of responsibility? What will happen if DSD goes further off the rails? How will this other woman discipline her? What is her ultimate punnishment - move to Woodend? What if by then Fiona and her husband have a newborn and Fiona will take time perhaps months even to recover fully from the debilitating SPD she is suffering, or the baby is challenging and the DSD is still not up there in the priority stake? Where dos she go then if being home is still not an option?

There are so many issues involved here, it is not s imple "she needs to learn her lesson" - she is still a child, and giving in to her tanturms and allowing her to get exactly what she wants may very well not teach her anything at all, except what she may very well think she already knows that is she is unwanted and too difficult to bother with, by either of her parents.

I feel very deeply for Fionas and what she is going through... I cannot imagine how difficult her life has become through this pregnancy and how she is coping day to day should be commended and I have no idea how she is doing it. But this is not a "rally for Fiona thread", it was a serious question (I thought) posed by a woman who is clearly in distress and need over a particualry trying circumstance, asking for help and opinions and perhaps experiences in something similar, which was all I was offering - my experience.
For me though the fact that DSD is being destructive is unfortunate and even revolting given Fionas situation (quite honestly my initial reaction to her behaviours in a previous thread was she needs a good smack on the arse, even at 17 years old) doesn't negate the responsibility Fiona has, and more to the point, her husband has, of dealing with the problems (and finding out the cause of her behaviour in the first place - there is a reason, she doesn't behave like this for fun) and handling it as a family, and as parents. That is what was signed up for when she came over and like I said earlier, if they cannot do that because of the immense pressure they are both under even without DSD's 'input', then IMO she should be put back on a plane and go home to her mother.



If I was a little harsh in my earlier post, I apologise. I did not mean to imply I had no sympathy nor empathy for Fionas very very difficult position, nor did I mean to offend anyone.