thread: no father on birth cert. Centrelink wont pay until someone is on there help

Hybrid View

Previous Post Previous Post   Next Post Next Post
  1. #1
    Registered User

    Dec 2006
    In my own private paradise
    15,272

    ask for an appointment with a social worker. explain the situation. from the perspective of c'link (and the government in general) the father has to be named as, accepting father unknown means it is negating the fathers responsibility to pay child support. it's only accepted in situations where it is truly unknown (like in rape cases - though some women will lie and say unknown one night stand to get out of naming a father)

    given the fact that DHS are involved, my guess is that he is going to be named at some point anyway - so it's definitely something that needs to go through social workers.

    if there is a concern re statutory rape charges, you'd need to contact legal aide about what happens if he is named.

    with regards to the consultant that gave them a hard time about paternity - tell them to put in a complaint. it's not a consultants job to make someone "confess" - if paternity is "unknown" it is to be referred to a social worker. someone was on a power trip due to the age of the mother - it's a crock - it should be referred immediately

  2. #2
    Lucy in the sky with diamonds.

    Jan 2005
    Funky Town, Vic
    7,070

    I do think a certain amount of pressure is warranted. It IS a rare case that they truly don't know - and to deny the name when you DO know (no matter what the situation) is not on.

    They do it for lots of reasons - lots of times because a friend did it and then goes and tells everyone else how they lied about it. OR they may be being threatened by the father that doesn't want to pay CS OR they are told by 'well meaning' friends that lying about it is fine.
    You can't change paternity for personal convenience.

  3. #3

    Dec 2005
    not with crazy people
    8,023

    I have to fullheartedly agree wiht Lulu. Having father unknown is a terrible thing to see on a birth cerficate.
    eg
    one of my besties eldest and her boyfriend spanked the monkey, split and found out later that she was pg. She knew who it was but still put father un known on DS' birth certificate. Then her and boyfriend patched things up and ended up getting married.....having 2 more children with fathers name on all certificates. Friends eldest son discovered his birth certificate and was an emotional wreak cause he thought his dad wasnt his dad and that he didnt love him. HE then had to 'adopted' his own son.

    It might not be easier now as you put it...but why not but up with the crap now when there are no children envolved rather then hurt their souls later in life.

  4. #4
    Registered User

    Nov 2007
    Where we swim in glitter and play on rainbows
    630

    thanks so much everyone and bg. Just to make it clear my brother and his girlfriend both want him on the birth cert. Just worried that the police can press charges without the parents request. It is a very horrible situation but they are both in it together and want to be a family. The law just wont let them. Bg i will def speak to legal aide today and get sil to put in a complaint about the worker. She has already seen the social worker who has said its ok if she doesnt know who the dad is. It is hurting her so much by not putting my brother on there cause they truley do love each other. Thanks again so so much xx

  5. #5
    Registered User

    Dec 2007
    Victoria
    7,260

    You really need to find out the exact legalities of the Stat Rape laws here in WA. Im not sure if they are dramarically different from vic or not.
    From my personal experience with them, which was 10 years ago now, Statutory Rape charges can ONLY be brought by the parents of the minor child involved.

    I will have a chat to a friend of mine today and get back to you about this.

  6. #6
    Lucy in the sky with diamonds.

    Jan 2005
    Funky Town, Vic
    7,070

    Clarify the law - I don't think there is anything stopping them. Don't make these decisions on assumptions ok? Put him on the birth cert - nothing is stopping them doing that either.

  7. #7
    Registered User

    Nov 2007
    Where we swim in glitter and play on rainbows
    630

    Thanks so much Limeslice I really appreciate it.

    Lulu - We will def find out the facts first. We thought that you could just change the Birth Cert in 2 years time when she is 16. We didnt know about all the rigmoral about adopting and things.
    I just hope it all works out for them and that my brother will not go to jail.

  8. #8
    BellyBelly Life Subscriber

    Jun 2008
    In snuggle land
    4,499

    I think they should go to Legal Aid. It looks like trying to avoid one problem may create a bigger one.

    • If your brother is not on the birth certificates, he has no legal rights to the child
    • They are currently lying to a government department. If someone dobbed them in (I imagine friends and family know), then they can be charged with breaking the law.
    • A child deserves to know who his legal parent are. As pp have said, denying paternity can have nasty consequences.
    • The basic fact is he has already broken the law by having sex with a child. There's a reason for the age of consent. If they get legal advice, fess up now, he can cop the consequences and then they can get on with their lives.
    • Harsh as this sounds, but I'd like to know that the parents of a child are taking financial responsibility for them, rather than expecting the tax payer to foot the bill. By avoiding having his name on the cert, he can get away with avoiding his financial responsibility, which the rest of us then pick up.

    I realise it's stressful and you don't want your brother to get into trouble. But he's a father and an adult. He needs to man up and face the consequences. Lying to one authority to avoid getting into trouble with another authority is child-like behaviour. He's just going to have to grow up so he can be an example to his child.

  9. #9
    Lucy in the sky with diamonds.

    Jan 2005
    Funky Town, Vic
    7,070

    [*]If your brother is not on the birth certificates, he has no legal rights to the child.
    Can you verify this? I'm not sure it's true. If he is the biological father of the child, those rights remain.

    I'd like to clear this up. It's quoted alot and if you get people running about not listing fathers on b/c for their own agendas it does more harm than good.