WDYT of this invitation??

[tan32]

Interesting
they were discussing these issues on the tv not long ago, and the issue was brought up about these parties getting out of hand and that the parents and teenagers should be charged if they allow under age drinking and charged if the party gets out of hand.

I wouldnt like to be the parents if a teenager gets hurt, has alcohol poisoning or worse. It may be different when it is your own children in your own home, but def not other peoples children in my home.

Alcohol has become so common and many people no longer see it as a drug, it does damage to young bodies and brains, at this age teenagers are struggling enough with judgement without adding alcohol to the mix.

I do like to have a drink, but its not often, i did drink when i was younger.

[Lady_Penelope]

Ok, so it seems there are a few people out there that feel it is "ok for a 16 yr old to drink under supervision".

Can any of these people tell me what they consider the appropriate "cut-off" age should be? 16, 15, 14..........or 13???

This is a little aking to putting one's DD on the pill "because most teens will have sex, anyway".

Seems to me that PARENTS are setting the standards bar way too long and inadvertently putting pressure on their own kids!

Tracy

[briggsy's girl]

Lady Penelope - i don't know that there is a certain "age" where it becomes ok - for me, i started having one or two drinks every few months with my parents when i was 13 - but i was, and always have been, very "mature" for my age. i also don't have an addictive personality. My DH, on the other hand, does have something of an addictive personality, so with our children, it will very much come down to the personality of the individual child. i won't say "ok, it's your X birthday, you're allowed to drink now" - i know children need to be treated equally - but that equality has to be about more than a number

i will admit that i'm sitting on the fence a lot with regards to this issue. personally, i've been involved in playing "security" at an underage party for a friends son - and we were extremely strict on who got in - and they only got to drink what they bought. we taxi'd each of them home so that they couldn't leave that party and go and get drunk elsewhere - no one was allowed to drink to excess. but i know not all parties go like this (look at the now infamous Cory!) - so i am well aware of how out of control these can get.

this thread has sparked some obvious debate - and i think debate is healthy - i've spoken to another member at length about this - and though we continue to have differing opinions, i think i've come to a new level of understanding about youngsters and what can happen in those with addictive personalities. i haven't changed my stance - i will be a fence sitter until i have teens myself and have to make that call! but i HAVE looked at it from another POV...

Lulu - you are the only person that can make a call on what YOUR child does - and i respect whatever that decision is - it's not up to anyone else to parent your child - and i guess that's a big part of this issue - where does it come into play that someong else has the right to be in charge of your child - if you DO let your child drink, how will they make the decision that your child has had enough - that's something that you need to decide. good luck in whatever you decide hun

[AngelPunks]

My father is European, I was brought up with alcohol around (when he died, mum continued this - her father was also European), I could have a drink when I wanted to, I learnt about responsible alcohol consumption. My children will have the same upbringing, they will not see people "write themselves off" at a BBQ having a few drinks (ok they will if I go to anything at my BILs place), they will see responsible alcohol consumption, at dinner etc NOT drink to excess as a way to have fun or relax etc. I can count on one hand how many times I've had a few too many in the last 5 years.

At 16/17 when all my school friends were going out into town underage drinking, I couldn't see the point, when I could go to the cupboard at home and mix myself a drink, without running the risk of being busted. Growing up, Friday night was hang out night at Mum's place (this continued until I went overseas at 22), we could drink on the back verandah, in a safe environment & either she'd drive my friends home or they'd walk (all my close friends lived within a 2-3 block radius).

I was reading an etiquette book the other night and it suggests for teens parties that you get the full name and parental contact detail of EVERY person at the party (home phone/mobile), so as the responsible adult there, if something goes wrong, or little jonny gets blotto, you can ring the parent and ask them what they want you to do or if they'll come and pick up little jonny, this puts the onus back on the parent of little jonny to deal with their own child's behaviour.

[sushee]

I personally don't think all teens at 17 have the capacity of decide on a life-long career (and the majority might think they are but more often then not end up training for one thing and doing something completely different) Legally they may have the right, but mentally many are still too young at that age.

Like I've said, I don't have a problem with you raising your child the way you see fit, but I have a problem with you allowing someone else's child to drink under your roof - that's not your call to make. My family's home was also where all my friends came to drink - I thought I was wonderful that my parents were so open minded, and even while we all had issues with alcohol, because they provided us with a 'controlled' environment, they still believed they were being responsible parents. I respect their right to their opinion.

But I am not of the same opinion now, and that is my right as a parent to my kids. Teaching responsible alcohol intake ideally would be the domain of parents, but yes realistically that doesn't happen because the environment these days is such that teens' alcohol intake seems to governed by the opinions of their friends and their friends' more permissive parents. If every parent respected the boundaries set by other parents, being able to find someone's house to get trashed at would be less likely. Many of you said that in your own homes, you weren't allowed to get trashed, but give one parent the right to decide for someone else's child, and you're giving all parents the right to decide for someone else's child, and not all parents would be able to enforce such a limit.

I actually used to be a parent who believed that it didn't matter if my kids had one or two drinks at parties, but from the feedback from my kids in recent months, they never had one or two drinks, they got smashed. Everyone did. And some of the activities that go on in these parties (yes while the parents of the party-holder are in the house, watching TV in their room) would make your stomache turn. So as 'controlled' as you think you're going to be able to be, once your kids are out of your house, you have no more control. I am now a mother of an formerly addicted DD, and I post in here because while 9 out of 10 kids may not end up like her, I pray you're not the mother whose child is that 1 out of ten. Because it's not about how good a parent you are, it's about how easily the temptation is available for them.

The one thing I regret most is how complacent I was that everything was 'normal' and 'under control'. Yes kids will still drink, yes kids will still have sex, but I am not talking about complete abstinence, I'm talking about parents supporting other parents with regards to teaching responsible drinking. That, to me, is not age specific either.

[Ca Plane Pour Moi]

Drinking at 15 isn't illegal (where I am) but sex at 15 is... as I don't condone sex outside of marriage there's no way my children will be exposed to the "it's OK to have sex whenever" attitude in the household where I grew up. Please don't compare the two, it is VERY insulting.

What age to drink... I figure if DS asks for a taste of wine then why not give him a sip? Obviously I'm not going to do that to a toddler, but a junior school child certainly. Alcohol doesn't cause any health problems UNLESS taken to excess (just like paracetamol - no one would say never to give a child a paracetamol, which is another drug that isn't vital to life) and has the odd benefit if taken in moderation (just like paracetamol!). That doesn't mean I'm going to encourage DS to have alcohol, that just means that if he's around 10-11 and wants a taste I don't have a problem with that.

Also, just because a taste of alcohol is allowed doesn't mean I expect DS drinking with every meal or every weekend. There's nothing wrong with saying no - another thing we will be teaching him. That's not "setting a bar" too low or too high, that's just teaching what is and is not acceptable. Legal behaviour that is not out of control is acceptable. I fail to see how that is bad parenting.

[Lulu]

One thing I want to make clear is that you may have opinions one way or the other but until the day you have to implement your beliefs, the day your child gets their first party invite, the day your child tell you her peers at school get drunk every weekend and have random sex at the age of 13, the day you actually have to FACE it in reality - well ONLY then you can really understand how this feels.

I am far from a teeltotaller (as those in live chat will know!), my family have run pubs for years, I have worked in the industry for years - I am not totally uncool. My daughter has purple hair, has had the odd taste of alcohol and happily fetches a beer for her granddad.

DD had a ****tail when she saw Priscilla with my parents. I didn't mind so much as mum made a big deal about her being grown up etc etc. We discussed it later, and she said she couldn't taste anything. I made a point of how you cannot taste vodka in most drinks and when she is old enough she must take care with who buys her a drink. Why? Working in a small bar one night 2 guys ordered 2 double vodka and oranges and 2 beers. The girls ID were ok, they were both just 18. So I (probably VERY illegally) only poured half shots of vodka (and charged for doubles), and watched whilst the guys got ridiculously drunk and foiled their dastardly plans.......
DD thinks this is cool and has learnt something too.

SO my entire point is I'm not just making one decision - NO DRINKING till 18.It's more than that. I'm not so desperate that I need my childs approval, or coolness rating. I am teaching her as I go, but I'm still saying no!
I'm also totally against this rite of passage (or lack of it) and the alcohol "be all and end all" of any teen gathering.
I will teach DD to properly drink alcohol. There will be no way any of those horrible alco-pops will cross my threshold. No cheap and nasty spirits. She will learn to mix drinks properly. If she can afford to drink when she is 18, she will do it with a bit more respect.
I am far more inclined to let DD have a drink (if and when b4 18), dependent on the circumstances. ie - Letting her have half or a full glass of champers (maybe after she is 16) whilst at the theatre is WAY different than buying her a few cheap vodkas and dropping her off at a party when the focus is falling over and keeping your hair free of spew.

I am going to seek clarification on the law here in Vic. I was under the impression that it is not in fact illegal to supply alcohol to any teen if they are under your roof. This is what upsets me greatly.

Sush - if I found out some kids parents were encouraging my daughter to drink I would be livid and I would take it very, very far. It would be a sad day for anyone that undermines my parenting- let alone to that extent. It must have been horrific for you and the family, I hope she stays on a better path and leaves those people behind. The f#@kers.

I was a horrible teen, but I knew a 'cool' mum. She had 5 kids, her house was full of teens and she loved it. She was beautiful and fun, had a HOT toy boy and drove us to the local underage discos.
She was also very strict. She had a beer or three after work, but no way did we until we were 18. She nudged us to school when we didn't feel like it, and made us call our parents if we were there late. You can be cool and a good role model. I am not going to lie down and say "bugger it they all do it anyway".
I am setting high standards for my daughter and I have high expectations of her, nothing wrong with that.

I haven't called the parents and I'm pretty sure she won't be going. She is not 16 yet and I plan on showing her other ways she can be grown up.

By having a bank account
Having a part timejob
Responsiblity to her family
Knowning how to conduct herself and have a convertation with adults.

Wow, seems pretty simplistic when you look at it but it's amazing how many parents neglect this sort of stuff and waste their time trying to be cool.......

Gawd I've been offline for 2 days and look what happens!!

[Lulu]

I just want to make it clear to everyone that I am not offended in any way by anyones posts. Not at all. I re-read the above post and it's coming off a bit shirty - I don't mean it!

Everyones circs are different, everyones experiences different, and everyone's child and peer groups different in their own way.

Mwah!

[Pandora]

ah cool, I thought you were cross with us all

[meow]

One thing I want to make clear is that you may have opinions one way or the other but until the day you have to implement your beliefs, the day your child gets their first party invite, the day your child tell you her peers at school get drunk every weekend and have random sex at the age of 13, the day you actually have to FACE it in reality - well ONLY then you can really understand how this feels.

I just feel the need to add to this that I raised my sister through her teens so while my sig doesn't reflect it I have been there. I know we're all cool but just wanted to point out that many people's life experiences can be more than we realise.

I'm glad you and your daughter have made a decision and all is well. It sounded full on to me. I was lucky with my sister that she wouldn't have even wanted to go- she was a damn easy teen really

[briggsy's girl]

i'm so glad you've come to a happy resolution Lulu - it truly does sound like your DD is a good one!