The best one I've ever had was a black Cellini one - it had all the requirements you're looking for and the leather didn't scuff. It's one of their basic classic styles that never gets changed.

I've gone through 3 Oroton wallets and been really annoyed at how badly the leather scuffs and gets marked. My next one will not be from Oroton! The reason I've gone back 3 times is because each was a different colour of leather, thinking it would not be as bad the next time around....i.e. had a cream, brown and black one and they all did it. As a functioning wallet though, they are great and their classic styles are the best.

Anyway, my only bit of advice, is don't do Oroton unless it's a fabric wallet.