My DD was a CS due to breech. With my DS I chose to go the Elective CS route after lots of indecision the whole way through my pregnancy, and I never had the burning desire to give birth vaginally.
I had pretty much decided by the 34 week mark that I would have a CS and was booked in at 39 + 5 weeks. I did however say to my ob that if I went into labour before my CS date I would have a go at VBAC.
Two weeks before my CS date we had a tradgety in the family and it made my decision all the more easier to go with the CS.
I knew what was going to happen, I could plan for my daughter as our family was 4 hours away, and as far as I was concerned, there would be no suprises and no undue stress.
As it turned out the cord was wrapped around DS neck twice so he probably would have went into distress anyway.
I have never regretted my decision regarding either of my CS, because at that time they were the right decisions for me and my family. I had very positive experiences for both CS, but having said that I will be planning a VBA2C for my next baby because I know if I don't try at least once to labour and have a vaginal birth, I will wonder later on in life. I still don't have the burning desire that some women do but I would like the experience so that later on I can draw back on it and give advice to my DD when the time comes. But that's just me and my personal choice.

You do whats right for you and your family. As I have said, I have never regretted choosing a repeat CS.