DH went with A and it was beautiful! He surprised me while watching the sunset on the rooftop of our cave house (hotel room) in Santorini, Greece. We bought a cheapo ($25) ring the following day which I wore the rest of our travels (several months back packing) until we bought the real deal in Hong Kong, which we chose together. I had the ring remodeled once home in Australia, after we'd had it valued.

I absolutely love the thought of DH's proposal, it still gives me goose bumps almost 10 years later!