thread: Jewish Pregnancy Customs

Hybrid View

Previous Post Previous Post   Next Post Next Post
  1. #1
    BellyBelly Life Subscriber

    Feb 2006
    South Eastern Suburbs, Vic
    6,054

    I'm not sure I agree with that Mayaness, but then, this isn't even the Christianity thread so I'll digress.

    That's an interesting topic SaraJane, looking forward to Yael's answer. Are there many other Jews around on the forums?

  2. #2
    Registered User

    Nov 2005
    Where the heart is
    4,360

    I forgot to qualify (actually, had a wriggly child on lap when last posting)...
    I was raised a Christian, mainly in Baptist churches, going to youth groups, Sunday School etc, went to Catholic primary and secondary school (my dad's Irish and this was the compromise for not being baptised...I'm such a heathen!).
    At school I had an ace RE teacher who knew that I was genuinely interested in these other theological questions, so sent me to an 'open day' at a synagogue in St Kilda, which I thoroughly enjoyed and reported back on. We used to come head to head in RE class all the time and I still can't believe that he respected me enough to send me on that great trip, where I really developed a deep respect for Judaism (and since have also done with Islam and Buddhism).
    So, my comments about Christianity and women come from my varied and many experiences within the Christian context. More power to you if you never had to hear this diatribe about a woman's curse etc! I did, and that is my experience. I let go of it long before I fell pregnant and feel better for it.
    That's way OT, and just giving background to also wanting to know if this article is a good reflection of the general Jewish approach to pregnancy.
    It's the social anthropologist in me

  3. #3
    Registered User
    Follow Dustmite On Twitter

    Oct 2005
    Montana, USA
    534

    So, my comments about Christianity and women come from my varied and many experiences within the Christian context. More power to you if you never had to hear this diatribe about a woman's curse etc! I did, and that is my experience. I let go of it long before I fell pregnant and feel better for it.
    As was stated in the previous post, the bible does say that labor will be painful. I know of no woman who can honestly say that child birth was without any pain....it is why man has created drugs for sale during such times

    With that said, I do not agree with any individuals/organizations religious interpretation that says there can be no enjoyment in childbirth. I believe pain and enjoyment are not directly tied together - if it was no one would be having children or at least not beyond the first. I believe God still left enjoyment in the entire process from start to beginning, but with the fall of man came a side of childbirth never intended for man kind (i.e. pain WITH enjoyment).

    Just my input for what its worth.

  4. #4
    Registered User

    Nov 2005
    Where the heart is
    4,360

    SJ's post sums up what I have gathered about modern Christianity's approach to the whole deal. I have also read this elsewhere. I never say 'the Bible' doesn't support women enjoying their bodies and processes, I say 'Christianity' as a tradition, as an institution.
    And, honestly, Dustmite...nothing I would honestly call pain in my birth! I know women who enjoyed their births more than I enjoyed my DS's...so there :P
    Also, I just can't abide by the thought of birth being relegated to a hardship - it just doesn't align with my experience and those of people I know!

Similar Threads

  1. Recurrent Miscarriage and Fetal Death Information
    By Inanna in forum TTC after Late Loss ~ Recurrent Miscarriage ~ Stillbirth
    : 49
    : July 31st, 2010, 02:45 PM
  2. Early Pregnancy and HcG Levels
    By Astrolady in forum OPK's, HPT's & Other Home Tests Discussion
    : 4
    : March 4th, 2009, 09:15 AM
  3. Pregnancy in traditional male job
    By Aranah in forum Pregnancy Forums
    : 4
    : November 27th, 2006, 04:39 PM