Can A Breast Pump Extract 100% Of Milk From A Breast?

Can A Breast Pump Extract 100% Of Milk From A Breast?

Many expectant mothers have questions about expressing breast milk.

One commonly asked question is whether they should purchase a breast pump during pregnancy.

The answer isn’t a straight ‘yes’ or ‘no’.

After the birth, if baby and mother can be together for all feeds, and if the baby breastfeeds well, the truth is there’s really no need to express at all.

However, there are times when a mother might need to express in order to provide breastmilk for her baby – for example, if her baby is born prematurely or has a cleft palate.

There are other situations, too, where a mother is returning to work and wants to express to maintain her supply and provide her baby with breastmilk when she’s away.

So, if a mother expresses her breast milk, what pump is best for her to choose?

The decision largely depends on individual circumstances.

You can read more in Belly Belly’s article Choosing A Breast Pump – 4 Things You Need To Know.

Can A Breast Pump Extract 100% Of Milk From A Breast?

One factor to consider before purchasing a pump is how well it removes milk.

Recently, manufacturers of a new kind of breast pump called Anabella claim their pump can remove close to 100% of a mother’s milk.

But is this true? Can a breast pump remove almost all the available milk from a mother’s breast?

Can A Breast Pump Remove Almost 100% Of Milk From A Breast?

There is no breast pump like a baby. A mother’s body is designed to respond to her baby, not to a machine. A baby who breastfeeds well will always be able to remove milk better than any breast pump can.

Unfortunately, the manufacturer of this new breast pump doesn’t provide any research to back up the claim the pump can remove close to 100% of the milk from a mother’s breast.

On the other hand, there is evidence to show babies remove between 63% and 72% of the available milk during a breastfeed.

If babies are only able to remove almost 75% of available milk, then what does this say about the manufacturer’s claim?

Furthermore, the same research suggests breasts don’t need to be drained completely at every breastfeed in order to maintain adequate milk supply.

So, although removing milk well and often is important, removing 100% of breast milk isn’t really necessary..

It can take quite a bit of practice to express breast milk effectively. A mother’s let-down reflex needs to be conditioned to respond to a breast pump.

And there are other things to consider when a mother expresses milk using a breast pump.

What Affects How Much Milk Is Removed With A Breast Pump?

There are many factors, other than the type of pump, which determine how well a mother can remove milk when using a breast pump.

These factors include:

  • Anxiety or stress about expressing ‘enough’ milk
  • Temperature of the breast and breast flange).
  • Size of breast flange (piece of pump held to your breast)
  • Suction level of the pump
  • Use of breast compressions or massage during expressing

For some mothers, expressing comes easily. For others it can be like hitting their head against a brick wall – they seem to get nowhere with it.

How Do Babies Remove Milk At The Breast?

The way a baby removes milk from the breast is also an important factor to consider.

When breastfeeding, babies remove milk by creating a vacuum with their tongue. The peak vacuum occurs when the baby’s tongue is at its lowest position.

The manufacturers of the new pump claim the pump recreates the tongue motion, as well as the suction, of a real baby.

However, videos of the new pump suggest it uses a peristaltic wave motion, instead of creating a vacuum, to remove milk from the mother’s breasts.

When you hear manufacturers make claims as though they are indisputable facts, it’s best to be wary – especially when they don’t supply any scientific evidence to back up the claims.

Until someone provides solid scientific evidence to support the claims about this new pump, my suggestion would be to save your money.

Recommended Reading:

Best Selling Breast Pump

Spectra Breast PumpIf you’re looking for a top breast pump, Spectra has become the popular choice for mothers all over the world.

The Spectra is an Amazon Top Choice product, due to loads of great reviews, like this:

“Yes, yes, yes, get it now! Loving this pump. I switched from the Medela Pump in Style and I have no regrets.”B. Pawlowski

“This pump is worth every penny. It’s super quiet even my friends commented on how quiet it was compared to the one they had. It has a rechargeable battery so you can carry it around which is super ideal and it has a light and many settings. Best pump ever.”Penny

“OBSESSED! Best thing ever. So much more comfortable, efficient, and slightly more productive. I love the way it sucks – it doesn’t hurt!” – Lori

Find out more information and prices on the Spectra here.

  • 64
    Shares
 

Renee Kam IBCLC CONTRIBUTOR

Renee Kam is a mother of two daughters, an International Board Certified Lactation Consultant (IBCLC), a physiotherapist, author of 'The Newborn Baby Manual' and an Australian Breastfeeding Association Counsellor. In her spare time, Renee enjoys spending time with family and friends, horse riding, running and reading.


One comment

  1. On the other hand, there is evidence to show babies remove between 63% and 72% of the available milk during a breastfeed. – See more at: https://www.bellybelly.com.au/breastfeeding/can-a-breast-pump-extract-all-the-milk-from-breast.

    Please note that you are misstating the outcome of the study, which essentially states that breastfeeding on demand is better than conforming to the averages. The approx. 62% of milk consumption is inconsequential measurement number which cannot be used to compare the effectiveness of babies vs. breast pumps for removing milk from breasts. For example if, during the study, mothers were told to increase the duration of the feed by 50%, it would largely result in more than 62% consumption of milk.

Leave a Reply

Please note: in order to prevent spam and inappropriate language, all comments are moderated before they appear. We appreciate your patience awaiting approval. BellyBelly receives many comments every day, and we are unable to approve them all as soon as they are posted.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

loaded font roboto